Israeli Cabinet Divisions Deepen: Minister Calls Defeating Hamas “Unrealistic”

The Israeli government is experiencing internal discord, particularly after War Cabinet Minister Gadi Eisenkot challenged the feasibility of defeating Hamas as a primary war goal and called for early elections. Eisenkot, during a Channel 12 News interview, acknowledged the significant impact on Hamas in northern Gaza but refuted claims of a decisive victory or Hamas’s diminished resolve. He emphasized the need for realistic expectations, avoiding exaggerated narratives of total defeat.

This comes as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pledged to continue the military campaign for a “complete victory” over Hamas. Eisenkot’s statements reflect deeper rifts within Israel’s coalition government and growing public dissatisfaction with Netanyahu’s war strategies. These differences have become more apparent as Netanyahu repeatedly insisted on the continuation of the military campaign, despite some Israeli troops being withdrawn from northern Gaza.

Eisenkot argued for fresh elections, citing diminished public confidence in Netanyahu’s leadership. He dismissed concerns about holding elections during war, stressing the importance of public trust in government. The Israeli War Cabinet, established post-Hamas’ attack on October 7, comprises ministers with divergent views, highlighting existing policy and approach differences.

This situation is complicated by the strained U.S.-Israel relations, particularly over Netanyahu’s strong opposition to the creation of a Palestinian state, a stance at odds with U.S. policy advocating a two-state solution. Netanyahu’s resistance to a Palestinian statehood proposal, which includes both the West Bank and Gaza, further distances Israel from its key ally, the U.S.

Political analyst Yohanan Plesner notes these divisions are now becoming more visible, while Reuven Hazan from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem observes the deepening divisions as the war surpasses 100 days. Despite the ongoing conflict, Netanyahu has not shown willingness to change his strategies, potentially leading to further political and diplomatic challenges.

The war in Gaza, triggered by Hamas’ attacks, has resulted in substantial casualties and destruction. Over 24,000 deaths have been reported in Gaza, and the conflict continues with no immediate end in sight. As the Israeli public’s focus might shift to pre-war issues once the conflict ends, Netanyahu’s political future and leadership approach remain under scrutiny.