BRUSSELS: The firm response Europe has pledged to planned U.S. tariffs on steel and aluminum imports is likely to stop short of triggering the trade war that open market supporters fear. U.S. President Donald Trump said Thursday the United States would apply duties of 25 percent on imported steel and 10 percent on aluminum to protect U.S. producers.
The European Commission called the step a blatant intervention that amounted to protectionism. However, while promising to act “firmly,” it made no mention of retaliation but instead spoke of countermeasures that conformed to World Trade Organization rules.
Trump tweeted Friday that trade wars are good and “easy to win.”
“When a country (USA) is losing many billions of dollars on trade with virtually every country it does business with, trade wars are good, and easy to win,” his tweet read. “Example, when we are down $100 billion with a certain country and they get cute, don’t trade anymore-we win big. It’s easy!”
Brussels will join other countries in challenging the measures at the WTO and says it will look into safeguards. Safeguard measures, last deployed in 2002 in response to steel import duties set by then U.S. President George W. Bush, would be designed to guard against a flood of imports resulting from the U.S. tariffs set to be formally announced next week.
However, they would have to apply to selected steel grades from all countries and so would hit producers from China, India, Russia, South Korea or Turkey.
U.S. steel makes up less than 1 percent of EU steel imports.
The European Union sees itself as a global counterweight to a protectionism-leaning Trump, sealing a trade deal with Japan, which had been part of a planned trans-Pacific trade alliance Trump withdrew from on his first day in office.
The EU is also seeking to conclude free trade deals with Mexico, now in talks with the United States to save the North American Free Trade Agreement, and the Mercosur countries Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay.
Retaliation would go against its long-standing message that global trade should be free – as well as fair.
Data from European steel association Eurofer shows the United States was the destination of about 15 percent of Europe’s steel exports in 2017, second behind Turkey with a 20 percent share.
The 3.4 million tons crossing the Atlantic to the United States is about 2 percent of EU steel production. Including tubes, the figure is 5 million tons, which Eurofer warned could be cut in half by the U.S. measures.
ArcelorMittal, the world’s biggest steelmaker with sizeable European and U.S. operations, said it was assessing the likely impact, although adding governments were right to take a tough approach to unfair trade.
Turkey’s steel exporters association said it did not expect a major impact on their exports to the United States. They make up more than 5 percent of U.S. steel imports.
Analysts from Jefferies said the actual measures announced next week could be more nuanced than an across-the-board 25 percent tariff for steel, which it said was politically unfeasible and viewed as a direct tax on U.S. consumers.
Europe, they said, was likely to respond quickly with safeguard measures – it took just 20 days to act in 2002 – and EU producers could secure more open access to the United States than rivals.
BSC analysts said the short-term impact for Russian steel stocks should be limited and said the measures were a “zero issue” for aluminum producer Rusal, which could easily send its products elsewhere at virtually no cost.
The Thomson Reuters European steel equities index fell 1.7 percent Friday, while London Metal Exchange aluminum prices were largely flat at around $2,150 a ton.
Commerzbank said even if the U.S. manages to reduce imports by implementing steep trade tariffs, the impact on steel and aluminum prices elsewhere should be limited.