‘Victoria And Abdul’: A 130-year-old story for our times

Judi Dench and Ali Fazal in a scene from "Victoria And Abdul" Photo by Focus Features, courtesy of the Venice Film Festival

VENICE, Italy: Grouchy, greedy and constipated – nobody could accuse Stephen Frears of kowtowing with his portrayal of Queen Victoria in his new film “Victoria & Abdul.” The director, who won a string of awards for “The Queen,” his 2006 depiction of Queen Elizabeth II in turmoil at the time of Princess Diana’s death, returns to royal questions in a tale of the current British monarch’s great, great grandmother’s friendship with a young Indian Muslim, Abdul Karim, in the final years of her long reign.

Set at a time when the British Empire was at its peak and India was its “Jewel in the Crown,” Frears’ script lampoons the pomposity, arrogance and ignorance of the Imperial age.

He says the convention-defying, cross-cultural relationship at its heart has resonance today, when Britain and India’s relationship has been transformed but racism and Islamophobia linger. “It was always meant to be funny,” Frears said. “I thought, ‘What film would Donald Trump most like to see?’”

Abdul (Ali Fazal) is an Indian Muslim prison clerk picked out, on the strength of his height and Victoria’s liking for tall men, to be sent to London in 1887 to present the queen with a gold Mughal coin as part of celebrations to mark her golden jubilee.

It is supposed to be a fleeting visit on which, he is repeatedly told, he must above all avoid looking directly at his empress, played by Judi Dench 20 years after her first turn as Victoria in “Mrs Brown.”

It is an instruction Abdul flouts and, having caught the sovereign’s eye, he is soon ensconced in the royal household, to the fury of her son Bertie, the future Edward VII, and a toadying clutch of buttoned-up courtiers and ladies-in-waiting who surround and stifle the monarch.

Fazal said he had delved into history books to get a grasp of Abdul’s unique experience.

“That time was so different and so essential to this fantastical little world that these two created at the middle of this massive British Empire,” he said. “The important thing was that we more or less humanized that era where there was protocol, there was racism and everything that we are still dealing with now.”

Frears’ film, which premiered Sunday, is being shown out of competition at the Venice festival, where the director received a lifetime achievement award at a gala ceremony.

The Victoria Abdul first encounters is frail and unhappy, a morbidly obese compulsive eater who is incapable of getting through her wolfed-down meals without smearing food across her face.

“I’m so lonely,” she tells her new confidant – 30 years after the death of her husband Albert and four years after the passing of her later-life companion, Scottish gamekeeper John Brown. “Everyone I’ve really loved has died and I just go on and on.”

Soon she recovers a glint in her eye as Abdul’s presence gives her a new lease of life. Dench said the offer to play Victoria again had been an “irresistible proposition.”

“It is very, very complex, her attitude to Abdul – not just a feeling of love, but the delight of being relaxed with someone without anyone around or any standing on ceremony,” she added.

Victoria and Abdul’s bond strengthens as he teaches her Urdu and introduces her to the Quran and Indian poetry.

By this time the scandalized royal household is in open revolt, with the irascible Bertie (Eddie Izzard), playing chief mutineer, even threatening to have his mother certified insane.

Victoria stands her ground but with his protector ailing, it is clear Abdul’s return to India is only a matter of time.

Abdul’s story, and the remarkable fact that Victoria learned sufficient Urdu to write letters in it – she initially knew so little of India she had to ask Abdul to describe a mango – went untold for over a century, largely because of Bertie’s efforts to destroy all evidence of it.

Traces survived, however, and some historical detective work by journalist Shrabani Basu brought the story back to life.

Her book, “Victoria & Abdul: The True Story of the Queen’s Closest Confidant,” was written after she discovered 13 of Victoria’s journals which, because they had been written in the Urdu Abdul had taught her, had been overlooked by British historians.

Via a nephew of Karim’s in Karachi, she then tracked down a diary that he had kept as well as some surviving correspondence between the two that had lain forgotten in the vaults of the Royal Archives.

The letters confirmed the degree of intimacy between the young man and the dying monarch. Invariably sprinkled liberally with kisses, Victoria describes her protege in one as a “true friend.”

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on September 05, 2017, on page 16.




Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here